How I Met Your Father
"Great friends. Meh decisions."
Overview
In the near future, Sophie tells her son the story of how she met his father: a story that catapults us back to the year 2021 where Sophie and her close-knit group of friends are in the midst of figuring out who they are, what they want out of life, and how to fall in love in the age of dating apps and limitless options.
What critics are saying
Critical consensus for How I Met Your Father was largely unimpressed, with most reviewers concluding that the spin-off fails to recapture the charm and energy of its predecessor. Critics widely described the comedy as stale and reliant on hollow nostalgia, noting that despite attempts to modernize the premise for 2022, the jokes, stylistic approach, and multi-camera setups often felt dated and detached from reality.
While the writing and contrived sitcom scenarios drew sharp criticism, lead actress Hilary Duff received praise for her natural charisma as a romantic-comedy lead, and Kim Cattrall was noted as game in her role as future Sophie. A few critics found comfort in the familiar, traditional hangout-comedy formula, but the prevailing sentiment was that the series offered little substantive reason to tune in beyond lingering affection for the original.
“The new series’ clearest advantage is Duff, who seems born to be a rom-com queen.”
“its every “modern” reference and joke setup still feel at least five years out of date.”
“offers no reason to watch other than fondness for the original”
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
The sitcom framework relies on the inherent chaos of modern dating. By centering the story on one woman navigating the overwhelming choices of current apps and personal ambition, the show updates the familiar trope of city living with a restless contemporary rhythm. It leans into the humor of miscommunication and the shifting dynamics of a tight social circle trying to stabilize adulthood.
Hilary Duff anchors the perspective as Sophie, a character defined by a search for genuine connection among frequent digital distractions. The narrative structure keeps the end goal present without letting it overshadow the immediate struggles of her friends. It captures the specific frustration of wanting life to align with long-term plans while everything else feels temporary.
Cast
Show 67 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where How I Met Your Father overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with How I Met Your Father.
-
How I Met Your Mother
2005
5 cast members
Alexis Denisof
Laura Bell Bundy
Neil Patrick Harris
Cobie Smulders
+1
-
Entertainment Tonight
1981
3 cast members
John Corbett
Hilary Duff
Neil Patrick Harris
-
Love, Victor
2020
2 cast members
Mason Gooding
Michael Cimino
-
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
2013
2 cast members
Clark Gregg
Kyle MacLachlan
-
Gossip Girl
2007
2 cast members
Leighton Meester
Hilary Duff
-
Reasonable Doubt
2022
2 cast members
Victor Rasuk
Aries Sanders
-
Jeopardy!
1984
2 cast members
Neil Patrick Harris
Joely Fisher
-
Marvel's Moon Girl and Devil Dinosaur
2023
2 cast members
Michael Cimino
Cobie Smulders
-
Interior Chinatown
2024
2 cast members
Alex Borlo
Erik Estrada Loaiza
-
Scandal
2012
2 cast members
Matt Letscher
Dan Bucatinsky
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Night Court
2023
7 crew members
Anthony Rich
Pamela Fryman
Conny Boettger-Marinos
Glenda Rovello
+3
Art Direction · Director · Production Design
-
Frasier
2023
7 crew members
Russell Griffin
Conny Boettger-Marinos
Gary Baum
Glenda Rovello
+3
Director · Director of Photography · Editor
-
How I Met Your Mother
2005
6 crew members
Pamela Fryman
Craig Thomas
Michael J. Shea
Missy Alexander
+2
Associate Producer · Creator · Director
-
Shifting Gears
2025
4 crew members
Anthony Rich
Ben Pollack
Stephanie Rabinowitz
Seth Yanklewitz
Casting · Director
-
Happy's Place
2024
3 crew members
Pamela Fryman
Glenda Rovello
Amy Feldman
Director · Production Design · Set Decoration
-
Love, Victor
2020
3 crew members
Isaac Aptaker
Adam Londy
Elizabeth Berger
Creator · Executive Producer
-
Mid-Century Modern
2025
3 crew members
Conny Boettger-Marinos
Gary Baum
Glenda Rovello
Art Direction · Director of Photography · Production Design
-
Vampirina: Teenage Vampire
2025
3 crew members
Phill Lewis
Kimberly McCullough
Morenike Joela Evans
Director · Executive Producer
-
Extended Family
2023
2 crew members
Russell Griffin
Jeff Cardoni
Editor · Music
-
Beacon 23
2023
2 crew members
Ben Pollack
Seth Yanklewitz
Original Casting
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
You and I Are Polar Opposites
2026
1 topic
romance
-
Extended Family
2023
1 topic
sitcom
-
Tomo-chan Is a Girl!
2023
1 topic
romance
-
Unknown
2024
1 topic
romance
-
In/Spectre
2020
1 topic
romance
-
Four Hands, Two Sonatas
2026
1 topic
romance
-
Chastity High
2024
1 topic
romance
-
See Your Love
2024
1 topic
romance
-
A Splendid Match
2026
1 topic
romance
-
Why Does Nobody Remember Me in This World?
2024
1 topic
romance
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- January 18, 2022
- Status
- Canceled
- Origin
- US
- TMDB Votes
- 302