Transatlantic

Transatlantic received a mixed-to-positive reception from critics, who largely commended its visual craft, rich atmosphere, and engaging performances, while expressing reservations about its execution. Set in 1940 Marseille, the historical drama earned praise for its striking visual design and its attempt to offer a unique, vibrant look at a dark period in history.

However, many reviewers felt the show struggled with a confused tonal balance. Several critics noted that the series often softened the gravity of World War II with conventional melodrama or an overly light, almost comedic touch that undercut the inherent tension. Others pointed out that the narrative lacked the sharp urgency and precision expected from creator Anna Winger following Unorthodox, leaving the plot feeling drawn out or convoluted at times.

Despite these narrative shortcomings, a segment of critics found the series to be an addictive, compelling homage to classic wartime cinema like Casablanca, celebrating its low-key heroism and relatable approach to historical resistance.