Best Mystery shows on Plex

Plex hosts a collection of mysteries that favors the methodical and the local. From the small-town secrets of Veronica Mars and Midsomer Murders to the period-specific investigations of Murdoch Mysteries and Father Matteo, these shows rely on a steady unraveling of facts rather than spectacle.

This page gathers these titles for easier sorting by tone and time period. Expect a mix of long-running procedural staples and youth-focused puzzles that prioritize detective work. Use the filters to move between these specific investigative styles.