Genre

Best Mystery TV shows

Every mystery series in TV Is Art's catalog, sorted by what audiences engage with most. Each title links to similar shows, full cast, and where to watch.

Modern mystery television thrives on the steady drip of concealed information, shifting perspectives, and audiences actively trying to outwit the narrative structure. The central pull is rarely just about who committed a crime, but rather how deeply the deception runs beneath the surface. High-stakes psychological tension and intricate puzzle-box storytelling have largely taken over traditional procedural routines.

This catalog gathers television stories built entirely around secrets, misdirection, and calculated reveals. The selection covers a wide range of tone and style, featuring series such as *Sherlock* alongside *Only Murders in the Building*. Every featured title offers a distinct narrative puzzle designed to keep viewers carefully evaluating clues until the truth comes out.

Each entry in this section approaches suspense from a different angle, testing how much information can be pieced together before the final revelation. Browsing this category leads directly to stories where motives are hidden, tension builds steadily, and nothing is quite as straightforward as it first appears.

Fool Me Once
7.2
2024 · Drama

Fool Me Once

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +5
Sugar
7.1
2024 · Drama

Sugar

Apple TV · Apple TV Amazon Channel +4
A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
7.5
2024 · Crime

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

BBC iPlayer · Netflix +5
Velma
3.4
2023 · Animation

Velma

HBO Max · HBO Max Amazon Channel +4
The Agency
7.3
2024 · Drama

The Agency

fuboTV · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +14
Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin
7.8
2022 · Drama

Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin

Crave · Crave Amazon Channel +4
The Stolen Girl
6.3
2025 · Drama

The Stolen Girl

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Riverdale
8.4
2017 · Crime

Riverdale

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +2
1899
7.4
2022 · Mystery

1899

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
Sleepy Hollow
7.4
2013 · Drama

Sleepy Hollow

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Agatha All Along
7.4
2024 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Agatha All Along

Disney Plus · Disney Plus +1
Monster
8.5
2004 · Animation

Monster

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix +4
Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World-
8.1
2016 · Animation

Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World-

Crunchyroll Amazon Channel · Crunchyroll +5
Medium
7.5
2005 · Crime

Medium

Paramount Plus Basic with Ads · Paramount Plus Premium +8
Black Doves
7.0
2024 · Action & Adventure

Black Doves

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
The Crowded Room
7.7
2023 · Drama

The Crowded Room

Apple TV Amazon Channel · Apple TV Amazon Channel +4
Dead Boy Detectives
7.6
2024 · Drama

Dead Boy Detectives

Netflix · Netflix +4
Disclaimer
7.5
2024 · Drama

Disclaimer

Apple TV · Apple TV +1
The Beast in Me
7.1
2025 · Drama

The Beast in Me

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix +4
The Boroughs
7.2
2026 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

The Boroughs

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
School Spirits
7.8
2023 · Mystery

School Spirits

Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount Plus +16
Big Sky
7.3
2020 · Crime

Big Sky

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Dark Winds
7.5
2022 · Drama

Dark Winds

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix +16
Missing You
6.2
2025 · Drama

Missing You

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix +4
Run Away
6.7
2026 · Drama

Run Away

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
Bodkin
6.5
2024 · Drama

Bodkin

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
Murderville
6.3
2022 · Comedy

Murderville

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +4
It
6.9
1990 · Mystery

It

Crave
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
7.6
2000 · Crime

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation

Paramount Plus Apple TV channel · Paramount Plus Essential +16
Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities
7.4
2022 · Drama

Guillermo del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities

Netflix Standard with Ads · Netflix +4
Tune In

Find your next mystery obsession

Sign up free, rate a few shows, and get recommendations matched to your taste.