A Good Girl's Guide to Murder
Overview
Five years after the death of schoolgirl Andie Bell, Pippa Fitz-Amobi sets out to uncover what really happened to her. Sal Singh, Andie's boyfriend, admitted to the murder before taking his own life, but Pip doesn't believe he's responsible and teams up with Sal's brother Ravi to uncover the truth. If Sal Singh isn't a murderer and the real killer is still out there, how far will they go to keep Pip from finding out the truth?
What critics are saying
Critical reception for A Good Girl's Guide to Murder leans moderately positive, with many reviewers embracing it as an engaging, breezy teenage sleuthing adventure. Critics frequently compare the series to a 21st-century update of Nancy Drew, praising its fast pacing, twisty narrative, and the engaging chemistry between sleuth Pip and partner Ravi. Outlets like The Guardian and The Independent highlighted the show's fun, binge-worthy energy, noting that while the plot has its share of contrivances, it remains thoroughly entertaining.
However, several reviewers voiced reservations regarding the depth and originality of the adaptation. Multiple critics pointed out that clues often fall into Pip's lap too conveniently and that the supporting characters lack the development found in Holly Jackson's source novel. Skeptical reviews, such as those from IndieWire and Ready Steady Cut, argued that the show functions merely as a lightweight, formulaic detective yarn that struggles to justify its teenage drama subplots and adds little new to the mystery genre.
“Expect leaked nudes, fake texts and Ouija board mayhem as our young sleuth Pip investigates the mysterious deaths of two kids from her school. It’s such perfect fun you won’t even care about the plot holes”
“Much of “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” works well as a mystery thriller. However, with only six episodes, Cogen and her writing team rely on more than a few coincidences.”
“likely a more than sufficient diet-detective series, free of the dramatic weight of its more realistic counterparts and bereft of any true charm, excellence, or originality.”
“A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder is notably uninterested in everyone except Pip and Ravi, and even then only in the context of the crime plot, so the young-adult fluff feels pointless.”
Where to Watch
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
The 2024 drama series A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder shifts the traditional amateur detective trope into a dark, intimate space. By centering the story on Pippa Fitz-Amobi, an inquisitive teen challenging a closed police case, the show favors low-stakes school settings against high-stakes criminal secrets. The suspense stems less from elaborate crime scenes and more from the tension of a small community where everyone has something to hide.
Emma Myers plays an investigator who is as dogged as she is vulnerable, moving through the mystery with a clear sense of purpose. Because the narrative is based on a young adult novel, the show maintains a focused, personal perspective on the lingering trauma of a murder in a quiet town. It functions as a tense thriller that asks whether one person can actually shake the truth loose from a town convinced it already knows the answer.
Cast
Show 57 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where A Good Girl's Guide to Murder overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with A Good Girl's Guide to Murder.
-
A Spy Among Friends
2022
2 cast members
Alice Barclay
Anna Maxwell Martin
-
The Bastard Son & the Devil Himself
2022
2 cast members
Misia Butler
Kitty Anderson
-
The Crow Girl
2025
2 cast members
Nicholas Page Hayman
Lu Corfield
-
The Jetty
2024
2 cast members
Peter Sullivan
Adam Astill
-
Boarders
2024
2 cast members
Nicholas Page Hayman
Rowan Wallace
-
Star City
2026
1 cast member
Anna Maxwell Martin
-
Ludwig
2024
1 cast member
Anna Maxwell Martin
-
Outrageous
2025
1 cast member
Orla Hill
-
Alice and Steve
2026
1 cast member
Yali Topol Margalith
-
Wednesday
2022
1 cast member
Emma Myers
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Wild Cherry
2025
1 crew member
Lucy Richer
Executive Producer
-
The Other Bennet Sister
2026
1 crew member
Asim Abbasi
Director
-
Murder Is Easy
2023
1 crew member
Danielle Scott-Haughton
Executive Producer
-
Agatha Christie's Poirot
1989
1 crew member
Tom Vaughan
Director
-
Obsession
2023
1 crew member
Matthew Read
Executive Producer
-
The Leopard
2025
1 crew member
Matthew Read
Executive Producer
-
Towards Zero
2025
1 crew member
Danielle Scott-Haughton
Executive Producer
-
The Woman in the Wall
2023
1 crew member
Lucy Richer
Executive Producer
-
The Gentlemen
2024
1 crew member
Tom Courtney
Script Coordinator
-
Peaky Blinders
2013
1 crew member
Frith Tiplady
Executive Producer
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
Riverdale
2017
4 topics
dark
teenager
murder mystery
amateur detective
-
Down Cemetery Road
2025
3 topics
based on novel or book
amateur detective
thriller
-
The Final Problem
2026
3 topics
murder mystery
based on novel or book
thriller
-
You
2018
3 topics
dark
based on novel or book
thriller
-
Foundation
2021
3 topics
intimate
based on novel or book
assertive
-
3 Body Problem
2024
3 topics
secret
based on novel or book
thriller
-
Father Brown
2013
3 topics
murder mystery
based on novel or book
amateur detective
-
Battle for Happiness
2023
3 topics
secret
based on novel or book
thriller
-
Dare You to Death
2025
3 topics
murder mystery
based on novel or book
thriller
-
Dexter
2006
3 topics
dark
based on novel or book
thriller
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- July 10, 2024
- Status
- Returning Series
- Origin
- GB
- TMDB Votes
- 381