All Her Fault
All Her Fault
Now Showing

All Her Fault

"All these nice people. Killing each other."

8.1
Yr 2025
Status Ended
Mystery Crime
Your Verdict
Unrated

Rate this show to unlock picks like it. Create a free account.

Back
Series Brief

Overview

In Chicago, Marissa Irvine arrives at 14 Arthur Avenue, expecting to pick up her young son Milo from his first playdate with a boy at his new school. But the woman who answers the door isn't a mother she recognizes. She isn't the nanny. She doesn't have Milo. And so begins every parent's worst nightmare.

Critical Reception

What critics are saying

Score 73 /100

All Her Fault drew a generally positive response from television critics, with many hailing it as an engrossing, high-tension mystery anchored by compelling lead performances from Sarah Snook and Dakota Fanning. Reviewers frequently praised the series for its relentless pacing and its insightful, often brutal examination of modern motherhood, guilt, and class pressures, turning an every-parent nightmare into compulsively watchable entertainment.

However, the show was not without detractors. Skeptics argued that the convoluted narrative strains credulity and relies heavily on familiar "rich mom" domestic-thriller tropes, noting that beneath its polished aesthetic and bursts of sharp insight, the plotting occasionally succumbs to melodrama and uneven emotional resonance.

“Sarah Snook’s terrifying thriller is an absolute pleasure to watch”

“compulsively watchable, worthy of the type of binge that carves a dent into your couch cushions”

“a middling entry in the rich mom mystery genre”

Transmission Paths

Where to Watch

Peacock Premium
US
Peacock Premium Plus
US
Sky Go
UK
Show 4 more
Now TV
UK
fuboTV
CA
Global TV
CA
StackTV Amazon Channel
CA
Why fans love it

The tension in All Her Fault centers on a singular, unbearable moment of domestic disorientation. When a routine school playdate goes wrong, the narrative moves away from traditional procedural tropes and focuses on the fraying nerves of those involved. Sarah Snook anchors the mystery, turning a premise rooted in parental anxiety into a sharp observation of how quickly a life can shift from mundane to catastrophic.

This 2025 miniseries operates as a claustrophobic crime thriller defined by its relentless pace. By stripping away typical detective work in favor of a personal, immediate investigation, the show prioritizes the psychological weight of a missing child over police bureaucracy. It avoids broad heroics to examine the suspicion simmering beneath the surface of a seemingly ordinary Chicago suburb.

Featured Players

Cast

Credited 58
Regulars 9
Longest run 7 eps
Sarah Snook
Sarah Snook
as Marissa Irvine
Jake Lacy
Jake Lacy
as Peter Irvine
Sophia Lillis
Sophia Lillis
as Carrie Finch
Michael Peña
Michael Peña
as Detective Alcaras
Dakota Fanning
Dakota Fanning
as Jenny Kaminski
Abby Elliott
Abby Elliott
as Lia Irvine
Jay Ellis
Jay Ellis
as Colin Dobbs
Duke McCloud
Duke McCloud
as Milo Irvine
Show 50 more
Johnny Carr as Detective Greco 6 episodes Melanie Vallejo as Sarah Larsen 4 episodes Tayden Jax Ryan as Jacob Kaminski 7 episodes Thomas Cocquerel as Richie Kaminski 6 episodes Kartiah Vergara as Ana Garcia 4 episodes Laura Brent as Aimee Babich 4 episodes Joey Vieira as Victor Beran 4 episodes Linda Cropper as Esther Bauer 3 episodes Rowan Witt as Brendan Hill 3 episodes Sachin Joab as Alex Wayans 3 episodes Jackson Tozer as Officer Kiely 1 episode James Huang as Officer Petrovic 1 episode Julian Maroun as Officer Salini 1 episode Soren Jensen as Officer Whitson 1 episode Orlando Ivanovic as Sam Alcaras 4 episodes Genevieve Hegney as Casey Alcaras 3 episodes Robert Kovacik as Newsreader 3 episodes Melissa Magee as Newsreader 2 episodes Louise Siversen as Chief of Police 1 episode Karla Hillam as Press Conference Reporter 1 episode Jacqueline McKenzie as Lousie Erikson 2 episodes Terence Crawford as Lee Logan 3 episodes Leigh Scully as Detective Scully 2 episodes Sahil Saluja as Amit 1 episode Shirong Wu as Yuko Sawai 1 episode Lauren Grimson as Reporter 1 episode Carlin Monteiro as Press Conference Reporter 2 episodes Caroline Brazier as Irene Murphy 3 episodes Angela Johnson as Press Conference Reporter 2 episodes Sally Cheng as Press Conference Reporter 2 episodes Dominic Masterson as Kyle Smit 2 episodes Greg Hatton as Terry 1 episode Justin Hosking as Diving Sergeant McNeil 1 episode Lliam Amor as Rick 1 episode Anita Torrance as Sam's Teacher 1 episode Jess Sofarnos as Cashier Miller 1 episode Juan Fernando Monge as Detective Monge 1 episode Zac Taylor as Sergeant Sacani 1 episode Brandon Ivanovic as Paul 1 episode Erroll Shand as Rob Murphy 3 episodes Monica Kumar as Medical Examiner Kumar 1 episode Cleave Williams as Motel Worker 1 episode Salim Fayad as Officer Porcaro 1 episode Tade Adepoyibi as Trauma Nurse 1 episode Bali Padda as Doctor 1 episode Alexander Chard​ as Paramedic 1 episode Stephanie Di Giacomo as Guidance Counselor 1 episode Isobelle Amie as Hospital Receptionist 1 episode Shin Hara as Lia's Lawyer 1 episode Daniel Monks as Brian Irvine 7 episodes
Production Board

Crew

Location Casting
Jane Norris
Hair Designer
Wizzy Molineaux
Director
Kate Dennis Minkie Spiro
Executive Producer
Joanna Strevens Sarah Snook Nigel Marchant Christine A. Sacani Jennifer Gabler Rawlings Megan Gallagher Minkie Spiro Gareth Neame
Writer
James Smythe Megan Gallagher Phoebe Eclair-Powell
Music Editor
Dave Jewerén Moore
Producer
Terry Gould
Post Production Producer
Jessica Rundle
Creator
Megan Gallagher
Associate Producer
Andrea Mara
Novel
Andrea Mara
Sound Re-Recording Mixer
Ben Tisdall Martin Jensen
Casting
David Rubin
Casting Associate
Djinous Rowling
Sound Effects Editor
Tom Stewart
Music Supervisor
Matt Biffa Ciara Elwis
Original Music Composer
Jeff Beal
Dialogue Editor
Lee Crichlow
Signal Match

Similarity

Where All Her Fault overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.

Keyword Cloud

Keywords

based on novel or book kidnapping nanny babysitter investigation miniseries missing child child kidnapping working mom anxious thriller
Technical Sheet

Details

First Aired
November 07, 2025
Status
Ended
Origin
GB
TMDB Votes
330