Overview
Dr. Mark Sloan is a good-natured, offbeat physician who is called upon to solve murders.
What critics are saying
Critical reception for Diagnosis: Murder has leaned cool and unimpressed, with reviewers categorizing the medical mystery procedural as formulaic. At its debut, the series faced harsh judgment from the Los Angeles Times, which panned the premiere as an outright failure and declared the show essentially "DOA."
Retrospective evaluations have characterized the series as mild and routine. Outlets like Around the Table describe it as a generic production that struggles to stand out, even as its traditional pacing and veteran cast offer a contrast to modern stunt-heavy procedurals. Meanwhile, family-focused assessments from Common Sense Media note that despite its focus on homicides, the 1990s drama remains relatively tame by contemporary television standards.
“'Diagnosis Murder' Is DOA”
“This is a very generic TV show which does not stand out from the crowd.”
“90s crime drama is tame by today's standards”
Where to Watch
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and weโll tune recommendations to your taste.
The appeal of Diagnosis: Murder lies in the uncomplicated chemistry between a father and son working alongside one another. While the central medical profession provides the setting, the cases rely on a casual collaboration between expertise and law enforcement. The procedural rhythm avoids the grim intensity often found in detective fiction, favoriting a lighthearted approach to the investigation of crime.
Dick Van Dyke anchors the show with a demeanor that keeps the tone grounded even when the mysteries become convoluted. The dynamics within the staff remain steady, providing a predictable environment where the resolution of a homicide feels like a natural extension of the charactersโ daily lives. It functions as a straightforward mystery series that prioritizes steady human interaction over high-stakes drama.
Cast
Show 67 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where Diagnosis: Murder overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with Diagnosis: Murder.
-
Trapper John, M.D.
1979
3 cast members
Pernell Roberts
Ken Kercheval
Joanna Cassidy
-
Star Trek: The Next Generation
1987
2 cast members
Denise Crosby
Susan Gibney
-
NewsRadio
1995
2 cast members
Kurt Fuller
Roger Hewlett
-
Touched by an Angel
1994
2 cast members
John Schneider
Charlie Schlatter
-
For All Mankind
2019
2 cast members
Robert Bailey Jr.
Charlie Schlatter
-
Boston Legal
2004
2 cast members
Steven Anderson
Joanna Cassidy
-
Murder, She Wrote
1984
2 cast members
Ian Ogilvy
Anne Lockhart
-
Bonanza
1959
1 cast member
Pernell Roberts
-
Young Love
2023
1 cast member
Harry Lennix
-
Passions
1999
1 cast member
Kim Johnston Ulrich
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Beverly Hills, 90210
1990
7 crew members
Burt Brinckerhoff
Anson Williams
Michael Lange
Nancy Malone
+3
Director
-
Dawson's Creek
1998
6 crew members
Michael Lange
Bruce Seth Green
Nancy Malone
Lou Antonio
+2
Director
-
Touched by an Angel
1994
6 crew members
Burt Brinckerhoff
Terrence O'Hara
Nancy Malone
Victor Lobl
+2
Director
-
Sliders
1995
6 crew members
Rick Avery
Hubie Kerns Jr.
Peter Ellis
Richard Compton
+2
Director ยท Stunts
-
Ally McBeal
1997
5 crew members
Oz Scott
Michael Lange
Alan Myerson
Sandy Smolan
+1
Director
-
Chicago Hope
1994
5 crew members
Oz Scott
Lou Antonio
Sandy Smolan
Michael Schultz
+1
Director
-
Martial Law
1998
4 crew members
Terrence O'Hara
Michael Lange
Bruce Seth Green
William Rabkin
Director ยท Producer ยท Writer
-
Gilmore Girls
2000
4 crew members
Bruce Seth Green
Alan Myerson
Neema Barnette
Michael Schultz
Director
-
Baretta
1975
4 crew members
Bruce Kessler
Burt Brinckerhoff
Bernard L. Kowalski
Michael Schultz
Director ยท Executive Producer
-
Knots Landing
1979
4 crew members
Michael Lange
Nancy Malone
Victor Lobl
Peter Ellis
Director
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
Shantaram
2022
2 topics
police
doctor
-
Sherlock
2010
2 topics
police
doctor
-
Hold Tight
2022
2 topics
parent child relationship
doctor
-
Law & Order
1990
2 topics
homicide detective
police
-
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
2000
2 topics
homicide detective
police
-
Cold Case
2003
2 topics
homicide detective
police
-
Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective
2025
1 topic
doctor
-
4MINUTES
2024
1 topic
doctor
-
Call the Midwife
2012
1 topic
doctor
-
Thirty-Nine
2022
1 topic
doctor
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- October 29, 1993
- Status
- Ended
- Origin
- US
- TMDB Votes
- 128