If Wishes Could Kill

If Wishes Could Kill received generally favorable, though slightly mixed, reviews from critics who praised its blend of modern tech horror and traditional Korean folklore. Reviewers highlighted the show's engaging premise, tense storytelling, and gnarly deaths, noting that after a conventional setup in its opening episodes, the narrative effectively subverts expectations. The fusion of high-concept smartphone horror with shamanic themes was widely recognized as a stand-out element.

However, several critics felt the series fell short of its full potential. Some reviewers noted that the show began to lose momentum in its second half, while others pointed out that promising character storylines were quietly sidelined over time. Additionally, comparisons to major K-drama horror hits like All of Us Are Dead left some critics wishing for a stronger, more consistent execution across the entire season.