The Paper

Critical reception for The Paper is mixed but generally leans positive, with reviewers split on whether it successfully carves its own identity or lingers too heavily in the shadow of its predecessor. Proponents praise the series for its earnest, grounded characters and its ability to mine tragic, modern-day humor from the decline of local journalism. Many critics found the lead performance by Domhnall Gleeson to be a major highlight, noting the show's potential to evolve into a clever workplace satire.

Conversely, some detractors feel the series initially struggles to find its footing, describing early episodes as clunky. Others have criticized it for feeling dated in its approach, suggesting that the mockumentary format can feel tethered to a previous era of television. While it is widely viewed as a solid, universe-building continuation of the "Office"-style comedy, consensus suggests it is still refining its narrative voice.