The Paper
The Paper
Now Showing

The Paper

"Finally some good news."

7.2
Yr 2025
Status Returning Series
Your Verdict
Unrated

Rate this show to unlock picks like it. Create a free account.

Series Brief

Overview

The documentary crew that immortalized Dunder Mifflin's Scranton branch is in search of a new subject when they discover a historic Toledo newspaper, The Truth Teller, and the eager publisher trying to revive it.

Critical Reception

What critics are saying

Score 75 /100

Critical reception for The Paper has been generally positive, with most reviewers finding it to be a charming and surprisingly effective expansion of the mockumentary universe established by The Office. Critics praised the series for avoiding cheap nostalgia and instead building an optimistic workplace comedy centered around a struggling local newspaper. Lead actor Domhnall Gleeson earned strong marks for anchoring the show with an earnest, engaging performance, supported by a warm ensemble cast and sharp writing.

However, reception was not uniformly glowing. Several critics noted early growing pains, pointing out that the initial episodes can feel clunky and hesitant as the show works to fully define its comedic voice. While a few detractors dismissed the format as dated and mediocre, the broader critical consensus views the first season as a promising, funny foundation with significant room to grow.

“Domhnall Gleeson makes Ned earnest and engaging as the centre of this charming, smart, thoroughly winning spin-off”

“The Paper‘s energy feels infectious thanks to sharp performances, writing, and editing.”

“Reminiscent of Season 1 of “Parks and Rec,” the first half of “The Paper” feels a bit clunky.”

“The Paper has no problem characterising local journalism as mundane and mediocre but, as they say, it takes one to know one”

Transmission Paths

Where to Watch

Why fans love it

The Paper transplants the mockumentary format from a fading paper supply company to a struggling newspaper office in Toledo. Domhnall Gleeson leads an ensemble tasked with keeping a historic publication alive in the American Midwest, replacing mundane office banter with the increasingly desperate scramble to find relevance in a digital world.

By shifting the lens to a dying industry, the series retains the observational humor of its predecessor while grounding the comedy in the particular anxieties of local reporting. It captures the specific rhythms of Ohio life, observing characters who approach the absurdity of their situation with earnest, misguided ambition. The result is a study of how people cling to their professional identities even when the world around them has clearly moved on.

Featured Players

Cast

Credited 75
Regulars 13
Longest run 20 eps
Show 67 more
Oscar Nuñez as Oscar Martinez 20 episodes Eric Rahill as Travis Bienlien 20 episodes Duane R. Shepard Sr. as Barry Strokes 20 episodes Tracy Letts as John Stack 2 episodes Allan Havey as Marv Putnam 15 episodes Robert R. Shafer as Bob Vance 1 episode Nate Jackson as Nate 7 episodes Michael Koman as Floor Worker 1 episode Phoebe Neidhardt as Emma 1 episode David Theune as Envelopes Guy 1 episode Mo Welch as Kimberly 10 episodes Tawny Newsome as Harper Brewster 1 episode Matt Peters as Gary Gladstone 1 episode Nick Thune as Parks Worker 1 episode Zaire Adams as Teen at Park 1 episode Jillian Craighead as Teen at Park 1 episode Mary Hollis Inboden as Cindy 1 episode Nancy Lenehan as Ann Putnam 9 episodes Jay Pharoah as Martin Lawrence (voice) 1 episode Julia Butters as Davey 1 episode Michael Hitchcock as Mr. K 1 episode Aidan Laprete as Wesley Holzwanger 2 episodes Ethan Cole as Student 1 episode Gia Blakey as Student 1 episode Madison Calderon as Student 1 episode Maksim Cherkashin as Student 1 episode Samantha Desman as Student 1 episode Clare Frazier as Student 1 episode Quinn Frazier as Student 1 episode Alexis Frias as Student 1 episode Chance Greene as Student 1 episode Aubrey Grier as Student 1 episode Ian Kebets as Student 1 episode Ethan Manor as Student 1 episode Sam Oh as Student 1 episode Janine Poreba as Teacher 1 episode Josh Holloway as Josh Holloway 1 episode Isaac Stephen Montgomery as Detective Arnold 1 episode Clint Culp as Catfish Victim 1 episode Paige Herschell as Gloria Tornado 3 episodes Cherie Laurent as Catfish Victim 1 episode Lidia Porto as Catfish Victim 1 episode Molly Ephraim as Summer 3 episodes Paul McKinney as Frank Durham 1 episode Gary Ballard as Glen 1 episode Matt Braunger as Dan 6 episodes Joshua Hoover as Man 2 1 episode Leslie Thurston as Secretary 1 episode Alex Flores as Garcia 2 episodes Linda Park as Casting Director 1 episode Billy Briggs as Patrick 2 episodes Jesse Abbott Chin as Albert 1 episode Rich Grosso as Sewer Worker 1 episode Patrick Kang as Softees Worker 1 episode Roland De Leon as Dante 1 episode Zak Messinger as Mateo 4 episodes Tyler Jeffrey Smith as Albert 1 episode Dylan Alvarado as Kid 1 episode Luzma Ortiz as Mother 1 episode Sam Huntington as Chris 2 episodes Kailen Jude as Allan 2 episodes Lisa Gilroy as Lisa Graysh 6 episodes Toks Olagundoye as Jeanie Lever 5 episodes Andy Richter as Carl 2 episodes Phil Hendrie as Salty Peanuts 2 episodes Jon Lovitz as Todd Dumph 4 episodes Peter Elbling 2 episodes
Production Board

Crew

Co-Executive Producer
Casting
Makeup Department Head
Executive Producer
Casting Assistant
Property Master
Unit Production Manager
Consulting Producer
Production Design
Hair Department Head
Producer
Casting Associate
Supervising Producer
Signal Match

Similarity

Where The Paper overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.

Keyword Cloud

Keywords

ohio mockumentary spin off newspaper office american midwest documentary crew follow-up
Technical Sheet

Details

First Aired
September 04, 2025
Status
Returning Series
Origin
US
TMDB Votes
108