Best Mystery shows on Disney Plus
Mystery series streaming on Disney Plus, ranked by audience engagement. Click any title for similar shows, cast overlap, and where else to watch.
Mystery on Disney Plus leans heavily into procedural logic and character-driven investigations. Shows like Criminal Minds and Law and Order: Special Victims Unit favor the methodical pace of forensic puzzles, while White Collar approaches the genre through the lens of a sophisticated con artist turned consultant.
Only Murders in the Building introduces a lighter, comedic tone to the collection of crime stories. Browse this page to sort through these specific titles by investigator type or case style. The entries below organize these detectives, feds, and amateur sleuths into categories based on their primary methods of solving a mystery.
White Collar
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
Criminal Minds
Only Murders in the Building
Gangnam B-Side
Lost
Moon Knight
Gravity Falls
Agatha All Along
The Acolyte
High Potential
Big Mouth
Revenge of Others
Big Sky
Moving
A Murder at the End of the World
Tengoku Daimakyo
Grotesquerie
Light Shop
Tell Me Lies
Goosebumps
Death and Other Details
Summer Time Rendering
The Judge from Hell
Grantchester
Link: Eat, Love, Kill
Class of '09
Why Didn't They Ask Evans?
Revenant
