Streamer × Genre

Best Mystery shows on Paramount Plus

Mystery series streaming on Paramount Plus, ranked by audience engagement. Click any title for similar shows, cast overlap, and where else to watch.

Mystery programming on Paramount Plus spans standard police procedurals, dark psychological thrillers, and deep-space investigative stories. Titles like NCIS: Los Angeles, CSI: NY, and Criminal Minds focus on behavioral profiling and forensic crime-solving, while Dexter takes a darker approach to the law enforcement genre. The catalog even extends into science fiction, using Star Trek: The Next Generation to apply classic mystery formats to galactic anomalies and futuristic cases.

This browse page organizes the platform's mystery selection into a clear format built for efficient browsing. Sorting through these options highlights the differences between episodic case-of-the-week dramas and long-form character studies. Selecting any show opens up tailored recommendations to help refine viewing choices based on specific story preferences.

Dexter
8.2
2006 · Crime

Dexter

Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel · Paramount+ Amazon Channel +15
Dexter: Resurrection
8.5
2025 · Crime

Dexter: Resurrection

Paramount+ Amazon Channel · Paramount Plus +13
FROM
8.5
2022 · Mystery

FROM

fuboTV · Paramount Plus Basic with Ads +13
Criminal Minds
8.3
2005 · Crime

Criminal Minds

Hulu · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +22
Star Trek: The Next Generation
8.4
1987 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Star Trek: The Next Generation

Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +14
Twin Peaks
8.3
1990 · Drama

Twin Peaks

Paramount Plus Apple TV channel · Paramount Plus Premium +13
CSI: NY
7.3
2004 · Crime

CSI: NY

Hulu · Paramount Plus Premium +10
Dexter: Original Sin
8.2
2024 · Crime

Dexter: Original Sin

Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount+ Amazon Channel +14
NCIS: Los Angeles
7.5
2009 · Action & Adventure

NCIS: Los Angeles

YouTube TV · Paramount Plus +11
The Agency
7.3
2024 · Drama

The Agency

fuboTV · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +14
Medium
7.5
2005 · Crime

Medium

Paramount Plus Basic with Ads · Paramount Plus Premium +8
School Spirits
7.8
2023 · Mystery

School Spirits

Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount Plus +16
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
7.6
2000 · Crime

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation

Paramount Plus Apple TV channel · Paramount Plus Essential +16
Quantum Leap
7.0
2022 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Quantum Leap

Paramount+ Amazon Channel · Paramount Plus Premium +3
CSI: Miami
7.7
2002 · Drama

CSI: Miami

Paramount Plus Premium · Hulu +9
Rabbit Hole
7.1
2023 · Drama

Rabbit Hole

Paramount+ Amazon Channel · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +10
Teacup
6.9
2024 · Mystery

Teacup

Peacock Premium · fuboTV +7
Red Eye
7.1
2024 · Action & Adventure

Red Eye

Paramount Plus Apple TV channel · Paramount Plus Premium +6
The Woman in the Wall
6.7
2023 · Crime

The Woman in the Wall

fuboTV · Paramount Plus Premium +12
Hysteria!
6.9
2024 · Drama

Hysteria!

Paramount Plus Premium · Paramount Plus Basic with Ads +6
Watson
5.0
2025 · Drama

Watson

Paramount Plus · Paramount+ Amazon Channel +11
Playing Gracie Darling
5.9
2025 · Drama

Playing Gracie Darling

Netflix · Netflix Standard with Ads +10
Tune In

Personalize beyond this list

Create a free account, rate a few shows, and get recommendations matched to your taste.