Watson

Critics generally viewed CBS's Watson as a mixed to underwhelming attempt to blend Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes mythos with a standard medical procedural. Many reviewers drew immediate comparisons to House, noting that the series brings the Holmes-inspired medical mystery full circle, though it frequently comes across as formulaic, derivative, and forced rather than inventive.

While star Morris Chestnut received praise for his commanding presence and for keeping the unsteady show afloat, several critics noted that his talents were wasted on weak writing. Outlets pointed out that the series struggled to naturally integrate its Sherlock Holmes backstory into a hospital drama, resulting in an awkward genre mashup that likely won't satisfy diehard Holmes fans.

Ultimately, while a few reviewers found mild comfort in its week-to-week genetic mysteries, the overarching consensus framed Watson as a uninspired procedural that rarely elevated itself above baseline network TV standards.