Based on a True Story
Based on a True Story
Now Showing

Based on a True Story

"True Crime is an obsession that never dies."

7.0
Yr 2023
Status Canceled
Your Verdict

Rate this show to unlock picks like it. Create a free account.

Series Brief

Overview

The lives of a realtor, a plumber and a former tennis star unexpectedly collide, exposing America’s obsession with true crime, murder and the slow-close toilet seat.

Critical Reception

What critics are saying

Score 58 /100

Based on a True Story received a mixed reception from critics, who viewed it as an energetic sendup of true-crime podcasts that ultimately struggles to deliver sharp satirical bite. While some reviewers enjoyed its dark, bloody humor and R-rated edge, others found the narrative messy and considered the show's commentary on true-crime obsession to be largely toothless when compared to similar genre-bending series.

The lead performances of Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina received consistent praise, with critics pointing to their charming dynamic as a key highlight. However, several reviews noted that glaring tonal issues and a lack of depth kept the talented cast from reaching their full comedic potential.

“Like “Only Murders in the Building,” this series is a clever sendup of ID channel programming, podcast culture and true-crime hosts...”

“This Peacock dark comedy targets a ubiquitous guilty pleasure, but its knife is dull.”

“a couple makes a killer podcast in fun, flimsy series”

“Kaley Cuoco and Chris Messina Anchor Messy, if Charming, Crime Comedy”

Transmission Paths

Where to Watch

Why fans love it

True crime obsession moves from the ears of listeners to the living room of a married couple in this 2023 comedy thriller. Kaley Cuoco stars as part of a duo that opts to capitalize on a local murderer rather than fear him. The narrative leans into the absurdity of the genre, prioritizing the logistical nightmares of professional exploitation over traditional suspense.

Set against the familiar polish of Los Angeles, the show mines dark humor from the domestic friction caused by a shared criminal secret. It balances the high stakes of serial investigation with the mundane reality of couple dynamics. The result is a portrait of a marriage tested by the temptation of fame, proving that in a city fueled by headlines, morality often takes a backseat to a successful audio project.

Featured Players

Cast

Credited 75
Regulars 5
Longest run 16 eps
Show 67 more
Annabelle Dexter-Jones as Serena 6 episodes Aisha Alfa as Carolyn 5 episodes Alex Alomar Akpobome as Ryan 4 episodes June Diane Raphael as Romy Lipinski 7 episodes Brandon Keener as Paul 4 episodes Miles Mussenden as Detective Quincy Burrell 4 episodes Britney Ortiz as Rebecca 2 episodes Pierson Fodé as Jamie 2 episodes Belmont Cameli as Mason 3 episodes Ava Catanzarite as Tess 1 episode Jill Lover as Lisa 1 episode Dawn Aneada as Roxie 1 episode Lynette Romero as News Anchor 1 episode Jennifer Kim as Kelly Monroe 1 episode Patrick McEnroe as Tennis Commentator 1 episode Jessica St. Clair as Rochelle Lipinski 7 episodes Aaron Staton as Simon 4 episodes Sebastian Quinn as Carlos 5 episodes Timm Sharp as Richard 3 episodes Yvonne Senat Jones as Detective Jessie Peterson 2 episodes Kellen Patino as Ollie 4 episodes Berkeley Grace Barrows as Jodie 1 episode Sophia Xu as Gabby 1 episode Matthew C. Flynn as Father 1 episode Graysen Moore as Son 1 episode Lizze Broadway as Dahlia Stone 1 episode Ever Carradine as Melissa Lake 1 episode Tani Hala as Self Defense Expert 1 episode Dominique Willingham as Flyer Guy 1 episode Valerie Tosi as Lady at Booth 1 episode Claire Holt as TV Writer 1 episode Robin Winston as Reporter 2 episodes Suzanne Dodd as Midwest Housewife 1 episode Ellysa Rose as Midwest Daughter 1 episode Dax Herrera as Westside Ripper Merch Guy 1 episode Delaney Guyer as Crime-Con Teenage Girl 1 episode Atticus Hinckley as Ted Bundy Bottle Opener Guy 1 episode Erik Nicolaisen as Ben Kaye 1 episode George Sear as Jacob 1 episode Robert Kovacik as Male Reporter 2 episodes Eric Artell as Auctioneer 1 episode Seth Fuentes as Teen Auctioneer 1 episode Ervin Ross as Subway Strangler 1 episode Bob Rumnock as I-20 Sniper 1 episode Aliya Kamalova as Spring Break Slayer 1 episode Alex Livinalli as Seattle Stalker 1 episode Hugh Scott as Night Prowler 1 episode Kingston Rumi Southwick as Jaden 2 episodes Stephanie Allynne as Christa 2 episodes Rory Scovel as Gustav 2 episodes Casey Wilson as Booby Bev 1 episode Emy Coligado as Tanya 1 episode Carter Graves as Mica 1 episode Lorin Doctor as Poppy 1 episode Chase Fein as Tyler 1 episode Anny Rosario as Carmen 1 episode Melissa Fumero as Drew 6 episodes Briana Cuoco as Park Mom 2 episodes Devin Way as Park Dad 2 episodes Brenda Koo as Park Mom 2 episodes Alberto Frezza as Jean-Michel 1 episode Audrey Trullinger as Young Woman 2 episodes Matthew Law as Nick 3 episodes Sara Paxton as Chloe's Sister 4 episodes Elisa Bocanegra as Georgia 2 episodes Joe Williamson as Detective Drew Stephens 2 episodes Josh Archer as Police Officer 2 episodes
Signal Match

Similarity

Where Based on a True Story overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.

Keyword Cloud

Keywords

husband wife relationship dark comedy serial killer los angeles, california true crime podcast comedy thriller
Technical Sheet

Details

First Aired
June 08, 2023
Status
Canceled
Origin
US
TMDB Votes
149