First Kill
"You never forget your first."
Overview
Falling in love is tricky for teens Juliette and Calliope: One's a vampire, the other's a vampire hunter — and both are ready to make their first kill.
What critics are saying
First Kill drew mixed reviews from critics, functioning primarily as a divisive, camp-heavy supernatural teen drama. Reviewers largely welcomed its central queer romance, praising the refreshing sapphic representation and the engaging dynamic between its two leads as a modern, monster-hunting twist on Romeo and Juliet. For many viewers, the show's unapologetic indulgence in genre clichés, family drama, and soapy cliffhangers made it fun, easy entertainment.
However, the series faced heavy criticism for its execution. Multiple outlets called out inconsistent and unfinished-looking CGI, corny dialogue, and cringeworthy tropes that undercut the narrative tension. While some critics enjoyed the series specifically when it embraced its trashy, melodramatic cheese, harsher assessments labeled it a tired and overly serious knockoff that ultimately fell flat.
“There's a new supernatural teen vampire romance to sink our teeth into, and it's more deliciously sapphic than any other mainstream teen drama on TV has ever dared to be.”
“At its most delectable, First Kill leans into the cheese.”
“The CGI throughout the series left me baffled at times because of the inconsistency. There were some moments when the CGI looked amazing and other times it looked less than stellar.”
“This sapphic soap about vampiric love is earnest enough to put a stake through the hearts of the genre faithful, but its clumsy execution leaves an aftertaste that's more garlicky than sweet.”
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
Adapted from a book, this 2022 drama pairs classic supernatural lore with sapphic romance. The mystery unfolds around Juliette and Calliope, two teenagers caught on opposite sides of an ancient conflict: one is a vampire, and the other is a vampire hunter. Their growing feelings for each other complicate matters just as both reach the point where they are expected to make their first kill.
The audience appeal rests on this central forbidden love story, which mixes teenage drama with the tension of rival families. Sarah Catherine Hook stars as part of a cast navigating the dangerous overlap between deadly duty and romance. By centering a lesbian relationship inside a genre mystery, the series offers a distinct take on vampire fiction where affection and deadly instincts collide.
Cast
Show 50 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where First Kill overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with First Kill.
-
HIS & HERS
2026
3 cast members
Jesse Gallegos
David Shae
Diana Lovell
-
Marvel's The Punisher
2017
2 cast members
Joseph D. Reitman
Jason R. Moore
-
Cape Fear
2026
2 cast members
Jesse Gallegos
Annunziata Gianzero
-
The Wonder Years
2021
2 cast members
Bill Winkler
Brooke Jaye Taylor
-
The First Lady
2022
2 cast members
Eric Esquer
Bill Winkler
-
Black Bird
2022
2 cast members
Brett Gentile
Christopher B. Duncan
-
Found
2023
2 cast members
Archith Seshadri
Patrice Fisher
-
The Thing About Pam
2022
2 cast members
Rachael Thompson
Sarah Stipe
-
The Lair
2007
1 cast member
David Shae
-
The Santa Clauses
2022
1 cast member
Elizabeth Mitchell
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Before
2024
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director · Executive Producer
-
Marvel's The Punisher
2017
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director
-
Avatar: The Last Airbender
2024
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director
-
Imperfect Women
2026
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director
-
The Copenhagen Test
2025
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director · Executive Producer
-
Tell Me Lies
2022
1 crew member
Emma Roberts
Executive Producer
-
Marvel's Daredevil
2015
1 crew member
Jet Wilkinson
Director
-
Ripple
2025
1 crew member
Amanda Tapping
Director · Executive Producer
-
Murder in a Small Town
2024
1 crew member
Amanda Tapping
Director
-
Landman
2024
1 crew member
Tito Tahan
Additional Music
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
Unknown
2024
3 topics
forbidden love
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
Interview with the Vampire
2022
3 topics
vampire
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
The Vampire Lestat
2026
3 topics
vampire
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
Fourever You
2024
2 topics
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
The Sign
2023
2 topics
forbidden love
based on novel or book
-
The Crowded Room
2023
2 topics
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
Someone Has to Know
2026
2 topics
vampire
based on novel or book
-
Heated Rivalry
2025
2 topics
based on novel or book
lgbt
-
Love, Victor
2020
2 topics
sapphic
lgbt
-
Petrichor
2024
2 topics
based on novel or book
lgbt
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- June 10, 2022
- Status
- Canceled
- Origin
- US
- TMDB Votes
- 351