Overview
Despite their opposing personalities, a talented but directionless P.I. who is the black sheep of his family begrudgingly agrees to work as the in-house investigator for his overbearing mother, a successful attorney reeling from the recent dissolution of her marriage.
What critics are saying
Critical reception for So Help Me Todd was divided, with reviewers praising the core relationship between stars Marcia Gay Harden and Skylar Astin while critiquing the show's tonal execution. Many commentators highlighted the family dynamics as the series' strongest suit, finding the awkward family relationships and Astin's comedic timing engaging enough to breathe life into a familiar procedural premise.
However, prominent critics took issue with the show's jarring shifts in tone. Reviews noted a distracting disconnect between the light, aggressively perky hijinks and the grim nature of the legal cases, which involved serious subjects like murder and assault. As a result, major outlets felt the series struggled to balance its comedic and dramatic elements into a cohesive whole.
Ultimately, while lighter episodic reviews appreciated the entertaining mysteries and character chemistry, broader critical consensus viewed the show as an uneven dramedy that struggled to find a consistent tone.
“its clashing tones make watching the show a genuinely jarring experience.”
“struggles to find a consistent tone across the three episodes sent to critics”
“a male detective appears to fumble through life but is actually quite proficient at his craft—but here, his relationship with his mom is at the heart of the show”
“So Help Me Todd (at least its Pilot) isn’t about murder mysteries or legal drama. It’s about the family dynamics. And that’s where the first episode really shined.”
Similar Shows
Show 5 more Show less
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
Legal procedurals often rely on rigid professional boundaries, but this series thrives on breaking them through a chaotic family dynamic. The story centers on the friction between an overbearing, highly successful attorney and her directionless private investigator son. Forced into an uneasy working relationship at her law firm, their clashing methods drive both the legal cases and the comedy. Marcia Gay Harden anchors the pairing as a mother navigating the aftermath of a dissolved marriage while trying to manage her wayward son as her in-house investigator.
Beyond the core mother-son clash, the series blends mystery storytelling with family drama, leaning into sibling relationships and office politics. Each case relies on the son's unconventional instincts balancing against formal legal strategy. The result is a character-driven mix of drama, comedy, and mystery where domestic arguments constantly spill into official investigations.
Cast
Show 67 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where So Help Me Todd overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with So Help Me Todd.
-
The Mighty Ducks: Game Changers
2021
4 cast members
Kapila Rego
Jane Stanton
Antonio Cayonne
Amy Goodmurphy
-
Animal Control
2023
3 cast members
Kalyn Miles
Lindsay Collins
Amy Goodmurphy
-
Watson
2025
2 cast members
Kalyn Miles
Inga Schlingmann
-
Homeland
2011
2 cast members
Laila Robins
Mark Moses
-
High Potential
2024
2 cast members
Rob LaBelle
Lily Yawson
-
The Hunting Party
2025
2 cast members
Katherine Haysbert
Mark Moses
-
The Night Agent
2023
2 cast members
Alex Rose
Hiro Kanagawa
-
Allegiance
2024
2 cast members
Candus Churchill
Amanda Khan
-
Blockbuster
2022
2 cast members
Daniel Whittaker
Barbara Wallace
-
Sight Unseen
2024
2 cast members
Hiro Kanagawa
Marlee Walchuk
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
The Hunting Party
2025
3 crew members
Alan Burdett
Allisa Swanson
Marcus Stokes
Construction Coordinator · Costume Designer · Director
-
The Irrational
2023
2 crew members
Calen Zantolas
Chris Alexander
Chief Lighting Technician · Key Grip
-
Love, Victor
2020
2 crew members
Amy York Rubin
Todd Holland
Director
-
The Waterfront
2025
2 crew members
Libby Goldstein
Junie Lowry-Johnson
Casting
-
The Girls on the Bus
2024
2 crew members
Libby Goldstein
Junie Lowry-Johnson
Casting
-
Best Medicine
2026
2 crew members
Scott Prendergast
Todd Holland
Director · Writer
-
Shameless
2011
2 crew members
Wendey Stanzler
Todd Holland
Director
-
From Scratch
2022
2 crew members
Libby Goldstein
Junie Lowry-Johnson
Casting
-
Alaska Daily
2022
1 crew member
Ruba Nadda
Director
-
Damages
2007
1 crew member
Nick Gomez
Director
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
Big Sky
2020
2 topics
overbearing mother
mother son relationship
-
High Desert
2023
2 topics
sibling relationship
private investigator
-
Bob's Burgers
2011
1 topic
sibling relationship
-
Down Cemetery Road
2025
1 topic
private investigator
-
One Tree Hill
2003
1 topic
sibling relationship
-
Reply 1988
2015
1 topic
mother son relationship
-
Extraordinary Attorney Woo
2022
1 topic
law firm
-
Mannix
1967
1 topic
private investigator
-
Damages
2007
1 topic
woman lawyer
-
Malcolm in the Middle
2000
1 topic
sibling relationship
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- September 29, 2022
- Status
- Canceled
- Episode Runtime
- 45 minutes
- Origin
- US
- TMDB Votes
- 63