The Completely Made-Up Adventures of Dick Turpin

Critical reception for The Completely Made-Up Adventures of Dick Turpin is mixed, with critics largely divided by the show's commitment to unadulterated absurdity. Fans of star Noel Fielding praised his whimsical charm and the series' silly, feel-good energy, often comparing its brand of humor to the anarchic style of Monty Python. Many reviewers considered it a lighthearted and entertaining watch that succeeds by refusing to take itself seriously.

Conversely, some critics found the show frustratingly "underbaked" or one-note, arguing that the heavy reliance on silliness comes at the expense of storytelling, character depth, or emotional resonance. While some outlets hailed it as Fielding's funniest work in years, others found the comedic efforts lackluster, suggesting the show struggles to find the necessary balance required to sustain its runtime.