Karen Pirie
Overview
When a 25-year-old murder in St Andrews becomes the subject of a provocative true-crime podcast, DS Karen Pirie is tasked with heading up a review. Digging up the past, Karen uncovers fresh evidence and a potential perpetrator. But when suspects start coming under attack, the cold case turns into an active investigation. Can Karen find the killer before it’s too late?
What critics are saying
Karen Pirie earned largely positive reviews from television critics, who widely celebrated the adaptation of Val McDermid's crime novels as a refreshing spin on the British police procedural. At the center of the praise is Lauren Lyle's portrayal of the titular detective. Reviewers appreciated that Pirie is presented as a relatable, normal, and engaging investigator rather than the brooding, deeply troubled figure typical of modern crime dramas, with critics highlighting her charm, wit, and grounded nature.
However, the show drew some mixed feedback regarding its execution and pacing. While some critics felt the extended episode runtimes allowed the story to breathe and truly sing, others found the narrative dragged in places, describing the conclusion as a bit of a slog or feeling that the procedural elements lacked bite. A few detractors also questioned the quality of the dialogue, though the general consensus remains that the layered mysteries and strong central performance offer an emotionally rewarding and entertaining watch.
“might be an unusually long adaptation of a single book, with three two-hour episodes, but it absolutely sings”
“a refreshing take on the genre”
“the emotional payoff proves rewarding, and the eventual revelations feel earned rather than contrived”
“getting to the end of the third and final episode felt like a long slog”
Where to Watch
Show 1 more Show less
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
The tension in this Scottish crime drama stems from the jarring collision between modern media and buried history. When a true-crime podcast pries open a twenty-five-year-old murder in St Andrews, the past stops being theoretical. The narrative relies on the methodical nature of reopening a cold case, but the pace shifts rapidly once the investigation evolves into an active threat.
Lauren Lyle anchors the series as the detective navigating the transition from desk work to a dangerous live pursuit. By placing characters in a landscape where secrets have been allowed to calcify for decades, the show explores how quickly composure dissolves when old evidence finally reveals new enemies. It captures the specific friction of chasing a killer whose identity remained hidden while the rest of the world moved on.
Cast
Show 67 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where Karen Pirie overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with Karen Pirie.
-
Dept. Q
2025
6 cast members
Gilly Gilchrist
Alec Newman
Conor Berry
Bobby Rainsbury
+2
-
Vigil
2021
4 cast members
Lauren Lyle
Jack Hesketh
Chris Jenks
Kim Allan
-
Outlander
2014
4 cast members
Gilly Gilchrist
Lauren Lyle
James Fleet
Gary Lamont
-
Six Four
2023
3 cast members
James Cosmo
Saskia Ashdown
Nalini Chetty
-
The Bombing of Pan Am 103
2025
3 cast members
Lauren Lyle
Beth Marshall
Marianne McIvor
-
The Witcher: Blood Origin
2022
3 cast members
Adam Young
Zach Wyatt
Mark Rowley
-
SAS Rogue Heroes
2022
3 cast members
Michael Shaeffer
Mark Rowley
Stuart Campbell
-
Granite Harbour
2022
3 cast members
Thoren Ferguson
Layla Kirk
Bhav Joshi
-
Game of Thrones
2011
3 cast members
Daniel Portman
James Cosmo
Ron Donachie
-
Wedding Season
2022
2 cast members
Bhav Joshi
Jamie Michie
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Malpractice
2023
2 crew members
Simon Heath
Elizabeth Binns
Executive Producer · Head of Production
-
Vigil
2021
2 crew members
Simon Heath
Marcus Wilson
Executive Producer · Producer
-
Silent Witness
1996
1 crew member
Priscilla Parish
Executive Producer
-
The Bombing of Pan Am 103
2025
1 crew member
Simon Heath
Executive Producer
-
Six Four
2023
1 crew member
Clare Kerr
Producer
-
Hijack
2023
1 crew member
Emer Kenny
Writer
-
Ted Lasso
2020
1 crew member
Ryan Kernaghan
Director of Photography
-
Luther
2010
1 crew member
Marcus Wilson
Producer
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
Foundation
2021
2 topics
based on novel or book
intense
-
Love Sea
2024
2 topics
based on novel or book
intense
-
Dept. Q
2025
2 topics
based on novel or book
cold case
-
Pachinko
2022
2 topics
based on novel or book
intense
-
Outlander
2014
2 topics
based on novel or book
scotland
-
Coroner's Diary
2025
2 topics
based on novel or book
cold case
-
The Traitors
2023
2 topics
intense
scotland
-
Run Away
2026
2 topics
based on novel or book
intense
-
Black Out
2024
2 topics
based on novel or book
cold case
-
Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective
2025
1 topic
based on novel or book
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- September 25, 2022
- Status
- Returning Series
- Episode Runtime
- 88 minutes
- Origin
- GB
- TMDB Votes
- 101