The Idol

The critical reception for The Idol was overwhelmingly negative, with many outlets labeling the series as a profound disappointment. Critics described the show as an "inert" and "witless" production, criticizing it for prioritizing sleaze and explicit content over coherent storytelling. While some reviewers noted flashes of potential in the direction and Lily-Rose Depp's performance, these glimmers were largely overshadowed by what many called a "sordid male fantasy."

Despite the high production value and moody, evocative soundtrack, the consensus suggests that the show failed to deliver on its promise. Reviews frequently highlighted the writing as lackluster, with multiple critics describing it as one of the worst programs of the year. The series is widely regarded as a try-hard disaster that ultimately lacked the depth or charm necessary to support its provocative premise.