Streamer × Genre

Best Mystery shows on Hulu

Mystery series streaming on Hulu, ranked by audience engagement. Click any title for similar shows, cast overlap, and where else to watch.

Mystery television on Hulu spans a broad range of investigative styles and narrative structures. The collection features comedic apartment-building whodunits like Only Murders in the Building, high-stakes legal thrillers like Damages, and sharp detective puzzles like Sherlock. Options extend to long-running procedural crime dramas such as Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, CSI: NY, and Criminal Minds, alongside capers like White Collar and the sprawling serialized enigma of Lost.

Filtering this specific intersection of platform and genre isolates the exact tone of mystery required for a viewing session. Each entry outlines essential story traits to make comparing a tight episodic case, a legal battle, or an island puzzle straightforward. Using these categorized options narrows down the platform's library into a manageable, targeted list.

Sherlock
8.5
2010 · Crime

Sherlock

Disney Plus · PBS +20
Lost
8.0
2004 · Mystery

Lost

Disney Plus · ITVX Premium +4
White Collar
8.2
2009 · Crime

White Collar

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Criminal Minds
8.3
2005 · Crime

Criminal Minds

Hulu · Paramount Plus Apple TV channel +22
Only Murders in the Building
8.4
2021 · Comedy

Only Murders in the Building

Disney Plus · Hulu +2
High Potential
8.3
2024 · Drama

High Potential

Crave Amazon Channel · Disney Plus +5
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
8.0
1999 · Crime

Law & Order: Special Victims Unit

USA Network · Peacock Premium +17
CSI: NY
7.3
2004 · Crime

CSI: NY

Hulu · Paramount Plus Premium +10
Damages
7.4
2007 · Mystery

Damages

Hulu · Tubi TV +6
Over the Garden Wall
8.6
2014 · Mystery

Over the Garden Wall

HBO Max Amazon Channel · Hulu +1
Gangnam B-Side
7.4
2024 · Crime

Gangnam B-Side

Disney Plus · Hulu +1
Fringe
8.1
2008 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

Fringe

Hulu · Amazon Prime Video +3
Good American Family
7.6
2025 · Drama

Good American Family

Hulu · Disney Plus +2
The Strain
7.5
2014 · Sci-Fi & Fantasy

The Strain

Hulu · AMC Plus Apple TV channel +16
The Stolen Girl
6.3
2025 · Drama

The Stolen Girl

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Sleepy Hollow
7.4
2013 · Drama

Sleepy Hollow

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World-
8.1
2016 · Animation

Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World-

Crunchyroll Amazon Channel · Crunchyroll +5
Big Sky
7.3
2020 · Crime

Big Sky

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
CSI: Crime Scene Investigation
7.6
2000 · Crime

CSI: Crime Scene Investigation

Paramount Plus Apple TV channel · Paramount Plus Essential +16
Agatha Christie's Poirot
8.2
1989 · Crime

Agatha Christie's Poirot

ITVX · Thirteen +24
A Murder at the End of the World
6.9
2023 · Mystery

A Murder at the End of the World

Hulu · Disney Plus +3
Murdoch Mysteries
7.7
2008 · Mystery

Murdoch Mysteries

The Roku Channel · Hulu +19
Grotesquerie
7.3
2024 · Drama

Grotesquerie

Hulu · Disney Plus +1
Class of '09
7.1
2023 · Drama

Class of '09

Disney Plus · Disney Plus +1
CSI: Miami
7.7
2002 · Drama

CSI: Miami

Paramount Plus Premium · Hulu +9
ERASED
8.5
2016 · Animation

ERASED

Hulu · Crunchyroll Amazon Channel +5
Luther
7.8
2010 · Crime

Luther

Hulu · HBO Max Amazon Channel +23
Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun
8.6
2020 · Animation

Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun

Hulu · Crunchyroll +5
The Apothecary Diaries
8.7
2023 · Animation

The Apothecary Diaries

Hulu · Crunchyroll Amazon Channel +11
Veronica Mars
7.8
2004 · Mystery

Veronica Mars

Netflix · Hulu +3
Tune In

Personalize beyond this list

Create a free account, rate a few shows, and get recommendations matched to your taste.