Best Mystery shows on Hulu

Mystery on Hulu spans the spectrum from procedural crime solving and high-stakes legal drama to supernatural anomalies and small-town true crime satire. The catalog shifts between the intense psychological pursuit of serial offenders in Criminal Minds and Law and Order Special Victims Unit, and the stylized, intellectual puzzles found in Sherlock and White Collar.

These titles cover a range of investigative tones, whether through the sharp, dry wit of Only Murders in the Building, the dark narrative layers of Damages, or the surreal, atmospheric world of Over the Garden Wall. Fringe rounds out the selection by introducing scientific mystery into the framework of FBI investigations. Browse the grid below to sort these series by thematic elements or specific plot mechanics. The collection focuses on maintaining a mix of linear mysteries and long-form character arcs to suit different viewing moods.