All's Fair

"All's Fair" received overwhelmingly negative reviews upon release, with multiple critics labeling it the worst new TV series of the year. The Hulu legal drama created by Ryan Murphy drew widespread condemnation for its empty wealth fantasy, weak writing, and superficial themes, quickly becoming infamous for earning a rare 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Reviewers widely panned the show's execution, describing it as a lazy and condescending take on "girlboss feminism." Outlets noted that despite a star-studded ensemble cast alongside Kim Kardashian—including Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Naomi Watts, and Niecy Nash—the high production budget and designer wardrobes could not save the series from feeling shallow and half-baked.

While isolated positive commentary commended the legal team's dynamic and drew favorable comparisons to Murphy's earlier work like Nip/Tuck, the vast majority of critics agreed that the show represents a nadir for its creator and platform.