Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story
"Are they monsters?"
Overview
The story of the Menéndez brothers, who were convicted in 1996 of murdering their parents José and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menéndez.
What critics are saying
Critical reaction to Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story was largely mixed to negative, with reviewers sharply divided over its handling of the real-life murder case. While several critics praised the standout, gripping lead performances from Cooper Koch, Nicholas Chavez, and Javier Bardem, the consensus took heavy issue with the show's sensationalist, lurid framing of severe abuse allegations.
Many critics felt the series suffered from profound tonal indiscipline, swinging wildly between agonizing depictions of physical and sexual trauma, tabloid melodrama, and jarring camp. Commentators widely noted that the second half of the season lost focus and authenticity, resulting in an exhausting and exploitative retelling that struggled to justify its existence.
“a salacious and exploitative retelling that finds its soul through stellar performances”
“Tonal indiscipline collides with high camp in Ryan Murphy's latest Netflix offering”
“The depictions of Erik (Cooper Koch) and Lyle (Nicholas Chavez) are equally gripping”
Similar Shows
Want personalized picks like these?
Create a free account, rate a few shows, and we’ll tune recommendations to your taste.
The 2024 miniseries explores the complex relationship between Lyle and Erik Menendez against the backdrop of a privileged life in Beverly Hills. By examining the lead-up to the 1996 conviction, the drama places significant focus on the internal dynamic between the brothers and the long-term impact of their experiences with an abusive parent.
Cooper Koch helps ground the narrative as it navigates the tension between the public perception of the killings and the brothers' own accounts of the event. The series avoids a simple procedural structure to highlight the specific familial pressures and psychological environment that preceded the parricide. It serves as a stylistic character study that centers on why two brothers eventually committed such a crime.
Cast
Show 67 more Show less
Crew
Similarity
Where Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story overlaps with other shows, and exactly what they have in common.
Shows sharing performers with Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story.
-
The Good Wife
2009
3 cast members
Nathan Lane
Jess Weixler
Dallas Roberts
-
Grotesquerie
2024
2 cast members
Ryan Maltz
Nicholas Alexander Chavez
-
Big Sky
2020
2 cast members
Jade Pettyjohn
Dallas Roberts
-
This Is Us
2016
2 cast members
Milana Vayntrub
Isabella Rose Landau
-
Margo's Got Money Troubles
2026
2 cast members
Jim Cody Williams
Brittany Freeth
-
Hope & Faith
2003
2 cast members
Michael Gladis
Jason Butler Harner
-
Fatal Attraction
2023
2 cast members
Peggy Dunne
Jason Jia
-
Monster: The Ed Gein Story
2025
2 cast members
Charlie Hall
Chloe Oloren
-
I Love That for You
2022
2 cast members
Peggy Dunne
Melissa Bailey
-
Love, Victor
2020
2 cast members
Leslie Grossman
Charlie Hall
Shows made by some of the same people behind the camera.
-
Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story
2026
13 crew members
Courtney Laine Koller
Kristen Davis
Will Thayer
Matthew Flood Ferguson
+9
Art Department Coordinator · Art Direction · Assistant Art Director
-
Monster: The Ed Gein Story
2025
9 crew members
Courtney Laine Koller
Kristen Davis
Will Thayer
Matthew Flood Ferguson
+5
Art Department Coordinator · Construction Coordinator · Creator
-
DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
2022
9 crew members
Ryan Murphy
Kristen Davis
Jason McCormick
Matthew Flood Ferguson
+5
Creator · Digital Imaging Technician · Director of Photography
-
The Shards
2026
5 crew members
Ryan Murphy
Simon Jayes
Jason McCormick
Ray Garcia
+1
Best Boy Grip · Camera Operator · Creator
-
Doctor Odyssey
2024
3 crew members
Ryan Murphy
Miho Suzuki
Sabrina Wilson
Creator · Makeup Department Head
-
The Watcher
2022
3 crew members
Ryan Murphy
Jason McCormick
Ian Brennan
Creator · Director · Director of Photography
-
Imperfect Women
2026
2 crew members
Brittany Madrigal
Karen Bartek
Hair Department Head · Key Hair Stylist
-
The Mandalorian
2019
2 crew members
Simon Jayes
Barry Idoine
"A" Camera Operator · Additional Director of Photography
-
The Beauty
2026
2 crew members
Ryan Murphy
Jason McCormick
Creator · Director · Director of Photography
-
Dark Matter
2024
2 crew members
Michael Ornelaz
Miho Suzuki
Key Hair Stylist · Makeup Department Head
Shows built around the same subject matter.
-
We Were the Lucky Ones
2024
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
The Bombing of Pan Am 103
2025
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Chief of War
2025
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Suspect: The Shooting of Jean Charles De Menezes
2025
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
The Big Cigar
2024
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story
2026
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Bed Friend
2023
2 topics
miniseries
abusive parent
-
The Glory
2022
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Candy
2022
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
-
Black Bird
2022
2 topics
based on true story
miniseries
Keywords
Details
- First Aired
- September 19, 2024
- Status
- Ended
- Origin
- US
- TMDB Votes
- 576