Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story

Critical reception for Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story leaned heavily mixed-to-negative. While some reviewers were mildly amused by its indulgent collision of gothic horror, camp, and grisly melodrama, most critics felt Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's latest installment prioritized lurid shock value over genuine storytelling substance.

A frequent complaint centered on the series' thematic shallowness. Several critics noted that while the show gestures toward exploring female rage and historical trauma, its rampant historical liberties, gross-out humor, and disjointed narrative keep it from making a coherent or insightful statement. The retelling was broadly dismissed as a messy and grueling spectacle that squanders its infamous subject matter.